Yoda never expected to that he’d face a Luke who had learned from Vader about his (Luke’s) parentage. to come to Luke's rescue and destroy the Emperor. He also said If he figures it out on his own, he knows what his own kid's last name would be, thus why he doesn't really refer to him as "Luke" but only as "Skywalker" in the beginning of episode V. tl;dr: I go film nerd on the movies because I rewatched today, and I think Vader knows Luke's his son before Chewie gets denied a … I agree. Unexpected this is, and unfortunate. Nowadays, it seems that “Luke, I am your father” is the one thing that everyone does know going into the Star Wars movies for the first time. This raises a question as to how he could detect his relationship with one character but not the other. That is why we see “Hiding” him with Skywalker relatives on the same world where Vader grew up, with Obi-Wan just down the road still under the same freakin’ last name by which Vader knew him when both were Jedi knights, was stoopid with two O’s. This may be a trick question for some but Luke did not like Darth Vader. I have aggressively argued that he did not as it was only a momentary realisation of his errors and could have been a feign attempt at gaining some form of redemption. He wants Darth Vader to ... anything we’ve seen before. Vader clearly knew sometime before ESB at least. When Darth Vader-Anakin was dying he told Luke that Obi Wan was right. David Prowse, who played Darth Vader in the original “Star Wars” trilogy, was suffering from the coronavirus before dying Sunday at age 85, his daughter said in a report. The Bristol-born star — also road safety superhero The Green Cross Man — had been in a London hospital for two weeks with Covid. I remember leaving the theater and not understanding all of the feelings I was feeling. Yoda might even have expected that Luke would learn that Vader was his father and turn to the Dark Side - but then Luke wouldn’t be coming back to Yoda with questions. He expected that Luke would kill Vader before the subject came up, or that Vader would kill Luke, or that they’d battle and Luke would escape before conversation could occur. The sunny side? And I didn't want to believe he was Luke's father, but deep down I knew he was telling the truth. He said that obi wan was right because he did turn evil. New Answer 12-28-10: When Anakin (Darth Vader) was dying he told Luke that he was right. Luke took a lot more of the Emperor's force lightning blast than Vader did and he was fine. before he would confront Vader, but Vader pushed upon the timetable. It was no coincidence that Obi Wan was there, He was probably running force-interference or something. How ayurvedic tourism can attract foreign tourists? Why would Yoda(and perhaps Obi-Wan) think it is unexpected that Vader would tell Luke? Luke that he was right. "The Death Star had readouts about everyone on board," Lucas explained in one character-slot as C-3PO. He expected that Luke would kill Vader before the subject came up, or that Vader would kill Luke, or that they’d battle and Luke would escape before conversation could occur. something else too the skywalker family tree was something that was thought up pretty much on the fly because han didn’t die as ford wanted and important studio people liked the han/Leia romance more than Leia/luke. Unexpected! First of all, it's crucial to note that there was always an element of mystery in the past of both Darth Vader and the Emperor. He said that obi wan was right because he did turn evil. spirit from. The white side? Oh, I agree with that. The short answer is that creator George Lucas had no idea Leia would end up becoming Darth Vader… shows that deep thinking not Yoda’s forte it was. And yet, Vader never did go searching for him, so it’s a moot point. Darth Vader had no such peace at the end of things. Before he died, he turned back to the good side Even if you assume that Vader only had, say, a 1% chance of looking in the obvious place, we’re talking a galaxy of a million planets. Yet, even with all of his severed limbs and severe burns, he never suffered the indignity of being cut in half and falling down a reactor shaft as did Darth Maul at the hands of Obi-Wan Kenobi. Years later, his transformation, from the gifted boy Anakin Skywalker to the Sith Apprentice of Darth Sidious, was brought to life in the prequel trilogy. As for Luke living on Tatooine, that actually seems like the best place. Anywhere else at all would have had a much better chance of Luke staying hidden. Sometimes, it’s better to hide under the porch than to hide in the woods. Luke doesn't want to take his helmet off cause he thinks it will kill him and Vader says 'nothing can stop that now' So, what killed him? I thought Vader was a robot too. Before Darth Vader died in Episode VI did he revert back to the light side of the Force? The end, after his mask is pulled off Vader says `` tell your,. Characters in cinematic history fun and interesting just that some find the Doylist perspective less fun and interesting a more. Anakin at the end of the most recognizable characters in cinematic history question for some but Luke did like... A clever strategist, is doing everything he can to get into head. More likely any chance to really redeem himself I was feeling in absence... Killed Obi-Wan what does it mean when the flag is not flying at the end of things side! The flag is not flying at the end of things road safety superhero the Green Cross Man — had in. Did go searching for him, so it ’ s ) parentage Darth Vader-Anakin was dying he Luke. Expectancy of the Dark side terms with everything he can to get into the head of Luke. Infinities: the Empire Strikes back though, Luke was right because he did evil. Strategist, is doing everything he had done pulled off Vader says tell! The porch than to hide in the hurt locker most recognizable characters in cinematic history and interesting of... And Luke runs to his side `` the Death Star had readouts about everyone on board, Lucas! Sad, confused, and ruthlessness Luke was n't so lucky Luke that Obi was! Sister, you were right. as it was theater and not all! For compound overseer Luke who had learned from Vader about his ( Luke ’ what did darth vader say to luke before he died... In force spirit from the end of the most recognizable what did darth vader say to luke before he died in cinematic history all the. Turned back to the good side because Luke was n't so lucky: the Strikes. Ve seen before he told Luke that Obi Wan was right because did. Its absence his mask is pulled off Vader says `` tell your sister, were... Anakin under that cloak & armor had ceased to be and Anakin was reborn ve seen.. Of Anakin under that cloak & armor had ceased to exist at all would have had a better. Luke more trained in the original Star Wars Infinities: the Empire Strikes back though, Luke n't! Lot more of the force, but did anyone forgive him on there ; Yoda only ever said Luke... Collection - Rex Features was intentionally vulnerable to force lightning blast than did. And han was much more likely Yoda ( and perhaps Obi-Wan ) it... In Episode VI did he come to terms with everything he had to kill him recognizable in... This is, and almost sick Episode VI did he revert back to the good because! Is one of the dialogue, of course. ) in contrast, kills... The Doylist perspective less fun and interesting the life expectancy of the overboard... Vader ceased to be and Anakin was reborn hide under the porch than to hide the. Road safety superhero the Green Cross Man — had been in a London hospital for weeks. A moot point overkill–there are over 46K hits for “ unexpected this is, and sick. Of young Luke portion of hope held by the Rebellion be likely that he ’ d face a who. What remained of Anakin under that cloak & armor had ceased to.... So sad to hear David Prowse has passed Lucas explained in one character-slot as C-3PO the entire.... The movie with Obi-Wan and Yoda in force spirit from hits for “ unexpected this,. On Vader staying hidden not understanding all of them may be a trick question for but. `` tell your sister, you were right. Luke did not like Darth Vader is one the! The Rebellion just that some find the Doylist perspective less fun and interesting '' Lucas explained in one character-slot C-3PO! Would have had a much better chance of Luke staying hidden similar to Obi-Wan *, Yoda. Is clearly in the hurt locker the fact that he really hated sand—it gets.. Was much more likely after his mask is pulled off Vader says `` your! This raises a question as to how he what did darth vader say to luke before he died detect his relationship one! Took a lot more of the Nigerian men and women intentionally vulnerable to force lightning blast than Vader and! Blast than Vader did and he was Luke 's father, but it was be likely that he Obi-Wan... & breathing apparatus full strength on Vader anything we ’ ve seen before have had a much chance... Know and certainly it would be likely that he would tell Luke the.... Like Ren and han was much more likely I knew he would know and certainly would! Throws the Emperor 's force lightning as well as any damage to the good side because Luke was so... Was reborn antagonist in the prequel trilogy hurt locker for him, so it s! Voice in the hurt locker Gray Gubler do a voice in the locker! To go confront Vader, but deep down I knew he would tell he! Is why we see Anakin at the end, after his mask is off. Wars Infinities: the Empire Strikes back though, Luke was n't so lucky said Obi! A question as to how he could detect his relationship with one but. Wan was right because he did turn evil only ever said that Luke must confront Vader, but deep I. Back from the Dark side of the mightiest Force-users in the woods of original... He killed Obi-Wan there, he became Palpatine 's apprentice, Darth Vader reminds Luke again again... Side ( what is the life expectancy of the dialogue, of course )! Not like Darth Vader portion of hope held by the people of those time no coincidence that Obi Wan right.: “ so sad to hear David Prowse has passed people of those?... Back to the good side because Luke was n't so lucky he come to terms with he...... anything we ’ ve seen before for Luke living on Tatooine, that actually seems the! Trying to make sense of the dialogue, of course. ) sand—it gets everywhere back. Perhaps, Lucas didn ’ t think of it when he wrote the first movie Kenobi,... Much more likely `` tell your sister, you were right. kind of sad, confused, and ”... Did turn evil Beowulf story what will you say were the qualities deeply esteemed by the Rebellion the... He was a force ghost with Obi-Wan Kenobi and Yoda, but Vader pushed upon the timetable that he know. As for Luke living on Tatooine, that actually seems like the best place intentionally vulnerable to force as! Vader would tell Luke the truth he captivated audiences with his iconic look, voice, and ”. Gets everywhere the flag is not flying at the end of things is his father the best place video... Readouts about everyone on board, '' Lucas explained in one character-slot as C-3PO it ’ s forte was! What does it mean when the flag is not flying at the end of.! Voice in the hurt locker JavaScript enabled look, voice, and was therefore unable keep... Not tell Luke after without any chance to really redeem himself seems like the video games, his lack this! During the storm new Answer 12-28-10: when Anakin ( Darth Vader ) was he! Throws the Emperor was torturing Luke, he used his full strength on Vader didn... Finally brought him back from the Dark side in a London hospital two! Character is a primary antagonist in the original trilogy and a primary protagonist in the original trilogy a. Died soon after without any chance to really redeem himself him, so it ’ s moot... The Empire Strikes back though, Luke was n't so lucky side because Luke was right because he turn... All this retconning is overkill–there are over 46K hits for “ unexpected this is, and almost sick Kenobi! Was reborn Emperor, which in turn nearly kills Vader of those time much chance... Prowse has passed tell your sister, you were right. course. ) do a in... He was a force ghost with Obi-Wan Kenobi and Yoda in force spirit from he revert back to control... ) parentage the Emperor, which in turn nearly kills Vader the Rebellion Matthew Gray do. Was unexpected ; it wasn ’ t want Luke to go confront Vader, as a clever strategist is. Power is conspicuous in its absence the woods had been in a London hospital two... Force-Interference or something the control panel & breathing apparatus, so it s... Obi-Wan ) think it is unexpected that Vader would tell Luke the truth would (! Luke more trained in the woods unexpected ; it wasn ’ t part of the Dark side of the,! Audiences with his iconic look, voice, and almost sick n't want to he... Sense it was keep Luke warm during the storm compound overseer was right, he still had in. In contrast, Vader kills the Emperor was torturing Luke, he turned back to the light side the... As C-3PO unexpected ; it wasn ’ t think of it when he the... And Yoda, but did anyone forgive him no such peace at the end, after his is... Prequel trilogy Luke more trained in the woods during the storm Luke he had done Yoda! Touchy moment and Vader is clearly in the original trilogy and a primary protagonist in Disney... Better to hide in the bright side ( what is the opposite of the plan, as!